Paramount Theatre | Aurora, IL | September - October 2011
Andrea starred as Eliza in My Fair Lady, the Paramount Theatre’s inaugural production. She received a Broadwayworld.com nomination for Best Actress in a Musical. Hedy Weiss of the Chicago Sun-Times called her “hilarious” in “the best Ascot Gavotte Scene ever,” and said “Prestinario is a petite, fiery actress with a superb, bell-clear soprano streaked with a uniquely golden warmth.” Musical direction by Shawn Stengel, who helmed a 23-piece orchestra. Directed by Paramount Theatre Artistic Director Jim Corti.